Short Answer
IT DEPENDS ON THE GOALIE’S REALISTIC PATHWAY.
This is not an important question at every age.
At younger Rep levels, both rostered goalies should generally receive meaningful playing opportunities. Therefore, the idea of choosing between being a permanent AA starter and permanent AAA backup may not even apply.
By U16–U18, however, hockey changes.
A AAA team may establish a legitimate starting goalie. Meanwhile, the second goalie could receive substantially fewer starts.
Consequently, AA Starter or AAA Backup becomes a genuine development decision.
Our answer isn’t simply:
TAKE THE TEAM WHERE YOUR GOALIE PLAYS MORE.
Nor is it:
ALWAYS TAKE AAA.
Instead:
FIRST DETERMINE WHAT KIND OF GOALIE PROSPECT YOU ACTUALLY HAVE.
That answer should influence almost everything that follows.
Why AA Starter or AAA Backup Changes at U16–U18
Our hockey development people include a former owner of the Kenesky Goalie School, along with decades of minor-hockey coaching and player-development experience.
In addition, our hockey-management background includes Junior hockey ownership and management. Therefore, we have experienced the transition from both sides: developing minor-hockey goalies and evaluating players for Junior environments.
At younger ages, development opportunities should dominate the discussion.
However, U16–U18 introduces another factor:
ADVANCEMENT.
Junior scouting matters more. Physical projection becomes increasingly relevant, while AAA exposure can become important.
At the same time, the number of available goalie positions begins shrinking dramatically.
For that reason, AA Starter or AAA Backup cannot be answered without evaluating the individual goalie.
Why Playing AA Can Be Better
GAMES MATTER.
A starting AA goalie experiences situations that practice cannot completely reproduce.
For example, the goalie must prepare mentally to start, manage pressure and compete when the score matters.
In addition, games require the player to:
- Read unpredictable situations
- Communicate with defenders
- Manage rebounds under pressure
- Protect a lead
- Respond after allowing a goal
- Handle strong and weak periods
- Play tournament games
- Compete in playoffs
- Perform when tired
- Learn how to win and lose
Therefore, regular AA starts can provide tremendous developmental value.
YOU CANNOT COMPLETELY REPRODUCE GAME EXPERIENCE IN PRACTICE.
Why Backing Up AAA Can Be Better
AAA offers something different.
Although the goalie may receive fewer starts, the player can potentially experience:
- Faster practices
- Better shooters
- Quicker releases
- Higher-level teammates
- More sophisticated systems
- Stronger competition
- Better tournaments
- Junior scouting
- Affiliate opportunities
- Higher-level goalie coaching
Furthermore, the goalie remains inside the environment where higher-level evaluation is more likely to occur.
Therefore, for the right prospect, AAA can remain valuable even without the starting position.
THE QUESTION IS WHETHER THE BENEFITS COMPENSATE FOR THE LOST GAMES.
Profile One: The Legitimate High-Level Prospect
This goalie has a meaningful combination of:
AAA-calibre performance
Strong physical projection
High-level athleticism
Quality technical development
Excellent goalie coaching
Mental resilience
Legitimate Junior interest
Continued development potential
For this goalie:
WE WOULD LEAN TOWARD AAA, EVEN IF THE PLAYER BEGINS AS THE BACKUP.
Why?
Because the objective is no longer simply maximizing games this season.
Instead, the family is trying to preserve and develop a realistic higher-level pathway.
AAA provides visibility. Moreover, the goalie can practise against higher-level shooters and remain around coaches who may influence future opportunities.
However:
THE AAA BACKUP ROLE STILL NEEDS A DEVELOPMENT PLAN.
Sitting isn’t development by itself.
Why Physical Projection Matters for Profile One
This is where families need an honest conversation.
At U16–U18, goalie size can materially influence higher-level evaluation.
Furthermore, the goalie is approaching Junior hockey, where younger players may soon compete against older, physically mature goalies for very few positions.
Therefore, if a U16 goalie already has strong size or a reasonable expectation of additional physical development, higher-level organizations may remain interested even when some technical development is still required.
A larger athletic goalie can sometimes be viewed as:
A PLAYER WE CAN CONTINUE TO DEVELOP.
The frame and net coverage are already present.
Technique can continue improving.
SIZE DOES NOT REPLACE SKILL.
However:
AT THIS LEVEL, SKILL DOES NOT MAKE SIZE IRRELEVANT EITHER.
Profile Two: The Strong Goalie With Limited Physical Projection
Now consider a different goalie.
This player may be:
Technically excellent
Athletic
Competitive
A strong AA or AAA goalie
Mentally tough
Dedicated to the position
However, physical projection and higher-level feedback increasingly suggest that elite advancement will be difficult.
Perhaps the goalie is smaller and unlikely to reach the physical profile higher-level teams generally prefer.
In addition, meaningful Junior interest hasn’t developed.
For this goalie:
WE WOULD LEAN TOWARD STARTING AA.
Why spend U17 or U18 sitting on a AAA bench primarily because the letters on the jersey look better?
Instead, play.
Compete.
Start tournaments.
Play playoffs.
Be the goalie when the game matters.
Most importantly:
ENJOY PLAYING THE POSITION.
Choosing AA Is Not Giving Up
This needs to be said clearly.
A goalie can have a tremendous hockey experience without reaching Junior A, college or professional hockey.
Therefore, moving from AAA to AA for meaningful playing time should not automatically be viewed as failure.
Instead, the family may simply be changing the objective.
The new goal could become:
Play meaningful hockey
Continue improving
Compete
Enjoy tournaments
Build friendships
Stay involved in the game
Eventually play college, club or adult hockey
Potentially pursue goalie coaching
Hockey doesn’t become worthless because there isn’t a professional contract waiting at the end.
Profile Three: The Uncertain Goalie
THIS IS THE HARDEST DECISION.
Suppose the goalie is 15 or 16 and still developing physically.
The player is technically strong but not dominant.
Meanwhile, AAA offers the backup position and AA offers substantial starts.
There is some higher-level interest, although nothing is concrete.
Now the answer requires more information.
Evaluate:
current height and physical maturity
reasonable growth projection
athleticism
AAA performance
expected AAA starts
quality of AAA practices
quality of AA competition
goalie coaching at both levels
Junior interest
affiliate opportunities
showcases and tournaments
mental readiness
what the goalie actually wants
Consequently, this family should not make the decision based on one factor.
THIS IS A PATHWAY DECISION, NOT A LETTER DECISION.
Don’t Let Wins Make the Decision
Suppose the AA coach says:
YOU’LL WIN A LOT OF GAMES HERE.
That’s nice.
However, wins alone don’t tell us how much the goalie will develop.
Our Junior hockey management experience included a goalie who finished approximately 32–1.
Nevertheless, scouts recognized that he played behind the strongest team in the league.
The record was extraordinary.
The higher-level projection wasn’t.
Therefore:
DON’T CONFUSE TEAM SUCCESS WITH GOALIE PROJECTION.
A goalie should be evaluated within the environment producing those statistics.
How Important Is the Goalie Coach?
EXTREMELY IMPORTANT.
Imagine:
AAA backup with excellent Junior-calibre goalie coaching
versus:
AA starter with virtually no position-specific development.
AAA becomes more attractive.
Now reverse it.
Consider:
AAA backup receiving generic team practices
versus:
AA starter working regularly with an exceptional goalie coach who has developed Junior or college goalies.
The AA opportunity becomes considerably stronger.
Therefore, don’t merely ask:
DOES THE TEAM HAVE A GOALIE COACH?
Instead:
Ask whether the coach:
regularly attends practices
works individually with both goalies
has developed goalies for your target level
understands your child’s physical profile
provides video analysis
develops the mental side
has a documented development record
can provide references
will give the family an honest assessment
The quality of the goalie coach can materially change the AA-versus-AAA decision.
How Many AAA Starts Will Your Goalie Actually Receive?
ASK BEFORE ACCEPTING THE POSITION.
A AAA backup receiving 15 meaningful starts is very different from one receiving four.
Furthermore, coaches may handle regular season, tournaments and playoffs differently.
Therefore, families should understand the philosophy.
Nobody needs to guarantee exactly 17 games.
However, the coach should be able to explain whether the team expects:
a tandem
a 60/40 arrangement
a clear starter
performance-based starts
different playoff usage
a developmental backup
That information matters before the roster commitment is made.
Can AAA Practice Replace AA Games?
NOT COMPLETELY.
AAA practice can provide exceptional development.
However, practice doesn’t fully reproduce:
pregame pressure
score management
late-game decisions
recovering after a goal
protecting a lead
overtime
tournament elimination games
playoff pressure
Therefore, a AAA backup still needs meaningful competitive opportunities.
Those could potentially come through:
AAA starts
affiliate games
appropriate tournaments
showcases
other permitted development opportunities
The important point is that the goalie needs a plan beyond simply practising.
How Important Is Junior Interest?
VERY IMPORTANT AT U16–U18.
If legitimate Junior teams are repeatedly watching the goalie, requesting video, communicating with coaches or offering practices, that is useful pathway information.
Furthermore, the absence of meaningful interest over time can also become information.
Therefore, families should distinguish:
WE THINK OUR GOALIE IS A JUNIOR PROSPECT
from:
JUNIOR ORGANIZATIONS ARE ACTUALLY TREATING OUR GOALIE LIKE A PROSPECT.
Those are not identical statements.
Could an AA Starter Still Get Junior Exposure?
YES.
Starting AA doesn’t necessarily close every door.
For example, the goalie may:
practise with AAA
affiliate upward
attend legitimate combines
participate in appropriate showcases
play in scouted tournaments
provide game video
continue specialized goalie training
Therefore, the family may be able to combine AA game experience with selected higher-level exposure.
That’s one reason the decision doesn’t have to be completely binary.
What Does the Goalie Want?
THIS MATTERS MORE THAN ADULTS SOMETIMES ADMIT.
Suppose your U17 goalie understands that Junior hockey is unlikely.
However, the player loves playing goal.
Now ask:
WOULD YOU RATHER START AA OR SIT AAA?
The answer may be immediate.
If the player wants to play, let that matter.
Conversely, another goalie may desperately want to pursue the highest possible level and willingly accept a difficult AAA backup season because the player understands the development plan.
Therefore:
DON’T BUILD THE PATHWAY WITHOUT ASKING THE GOALIE WHO HAS TO LIVE IT.
AA Starter or AAA Backup: Our Hockey Answer
PROFILE ONE: LEGITIMATE HIGH-LEVEL PROSPECT
Lean AAA, even initially as the backup, provided there is a genuine development and playing plan.
PROFILE TWO: STRONG GOALIE WITH LIMITED ELITE PROJECTION
Lean AA starter.
Play meaningful games and enjoy being the goalie.
PROFILE THREE: UNCERTAIN PROJECTION
Investigate before deciding.
Evaluate physical projection, athleticism, goalie coaching, expected starts, Junior interest, exposure opportunities and the player’s goals.
Therefore, there isn’t one universal answer.
THE RIGHT QUESTION ISN’T AA OR AAA.
It’s:
WHICH ENVIRONMENT BEST SERVES THIS PARTICULAR GOALIE’S REALISTIC FUTURE?
That answer can be different for two goalies of exactly the same age.
We Report What the Research Finds
Hockey rarely produces complete agreement. However, the independent information reviewed strongly supports meaningful game experience, specialized goalie development and progressive exposure to higher competitive levels.
In addition, elite goalie evaluation consistently considers physical projection, athleticism, technical development and future potential.
Therefore, Search the Hockey Answer™ does not support a universal rule that starting AA is always superior to backing up AAA.
Likewise, we found no basis for claiming that the AAA label automatically provides better development.
Consequently, the individual goalie’s pathway must determine the decision.
EXPERIENCE IDENTIFIES THE QUESTION.
RESEARCH TESTS THE ANSWER.
WE REPORT WHAT WE FIND.
Have Another Hockey Question?
Perhaps your goalie has been offered a AAA backup position while AA offers substantial playing time. Alternatively, you may be trying to determine whether your child’s Junior pathway remains realistic.
Contact The Hockey Resource™ with your hockey question.
Your situation may become another Search the Hockey Answer™ and help another goalie family facing the same decision.
Search Other Hockey Answers
USE GOALIES AS YOUR SEARCH TERM:
What Changes at U16–U18?
How Important Is Size at U16–U18?
What Makes You a Legitimate Junior Hockey Prospect?
How Do You Know if a Junior Team Is Really Interested?
As always, thank you for being part of The Hockey Resource Community.
NEW TOURNAMENT SEARCH APP – https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.hockeyresource.hockeytournamentapp&hl=en_CA&pli=1
AMAZON HOCKEY – https://thehockeyresource.com/discount-hockey-products-amazon/
NEW!!! The Hockey Moments Cards – thehockeytournamentresource.com
GUMROAD – EBooks https://thehockeyresource.gumroad.com/
SEE My Interview with the Mental Health Academy https://www.buzzsprout.com/1824112/episodes/13519482
SEE My Interview on Podcast with Constant Sports
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8VJUTfAGp
The most remarkable speech in Hockey History https://www.youtube.com/shorts/Y6GiyAkTZzQ
Actor Jeff Daniels Hockey Father about the drive home. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e51d9xCz3eU
Little Laslo is worth the watch, LOL. https://www.facebook.com/reel/3577382982556655