By Michael Orlotti | October 17, 2024
The Ontario Hockey Federation (OHF) recently discussed an open borders policy across Ontario, marking a significant change in the organization’s approach to player movement and team recruitment. This decision has sparked considerable discussion within the hockey community, with proponents and critics weighing its potential impacts.
Check Out Our Vrsus Apparel Store That Is Made By Hockey Players for Hockey Players
A Direct Statement From The OHL – WWW.OHF.ON.CA
Review of Player Movement
Date: Sep, 19, 2024 12:00 PM EDT
“The Ontario Hockey Federation (OHF), in collaboration with its Members that have jurisdiction over minor hockey (ALLIANCE, GTHL, NOHA, and OMHA), is conducting a comprehensive review of player movement regulations across all divisions (ages) and categories (e.g., AAA, BB) over the next four (4) months. This initiative aims to develop a more streamlined, family-focused system that enhances the experience for players and families while supporting the sustainability of hockey associations.
The OHF and its Members will actively engage with Minor Hockey Associations and stakeholders to identify and standardize the approach to player movement across the OHF. By aligning these regulations, the OHF seeks to minimize confusion and administrative challenges for families, ensuring a seamless and transparent transition for players as they advance through various levels of hockey.”
Any questions, email communications@ohf.on.ca
Understanding Open Borders in Hockey
As a parent whose child played in the GTHL and is now playing in the OMHA (classified as an import player), I would like to look at how this can impact players and organizations. In hockey, open borders refer to a policy allowing players to move freely between teams and regions without restrictions. This means players can join any team within the OHF’s jurisdiction, regardless of their place of residence or previous team affiliations. Therefore, no permission to skate form is needed and/or import player designation.
Pros of Open Borders
Increased Opportunities for Players – Open borders provide players with more options to find teams that best suit their skill level and development needs. This flexibility can lead to improved player experiences and potentially faster skill progression.
Enhanced Competition – With players able to move freely, teams can recruit talent from a wider pool, potentially raising the overall level of competition across the league
Simplified Administrative Process – The removal of transfer restrictions can reduce paperwork and administrative burdens for both players and teams. The OHF would also need to revise or eliminate current policies around player transfers, residency requirements, and team formation. This, too, would likely reduce some administrative burdens related to managing player movement.
Cons of Open Borders
Potential for Team Imbalance – Without restrictions, there’s a risk that stronger teams may attract a disproportionate number of talented players, leading to competitive imbalances
Impact on Local Community Teams – Smaller, community-based teams may struggle to retain players who are drawn to more prominent or successful programs. Some will worry that these small centres would have to shut down as a result.
Increased Travel Demands – With players potentially joining teams farther from home, there may be increased travel requirements for both players and their families.
Best Course of Action
Given the complex nature of this issue, the OHF should consider the following actions:
Implement a Monitoring System – Closely track player movements and team compositions to identify any emerging imbalances or issues.
Establish Support Mechanisms – Develop programs to assist smaller or struggling teams in player retention and development.
Create Guidelines – While maintaining open borders, introduce guidelines to encourage responsible recruitment practices.
Regular Review – Conduct annual reviews of the policy’s impacts, involving feedback from players, coaches, and administrators.
Phased Implementation – Consider a gradual rollout of the open borders policy, allowing for adjustments based on observed outcomes.
In Conclusion
The OHF’s implementation of open borders across Ontario represents a bold step towards increasing player mobility and potentially enhancing the competitive landscape of youth hockey in the province. While the policy offers numerous benefits, including greater opportunities for player development and increased competition, it also presents challenges that need to be carefully managed
The success of this initiative will largely depend on how well the OHF can balance the advantages of player freedom with the need to maintain a competitive balance and support local hockey communities. By implementing a robust monitoring system, providing support to potentially disadvantaged teams, and remaining flexible in their approach, the OHF can work towards maximizing the benefits of open borders while mitigating potential drawbacks. Ultimately, the impact of this policy will become clearer over time, and its effectiveness will likely require ongoing assessment and potential adjustments. The hockey community in Ontario will be watching closely to see how this significant change shapes the future of youth hockey in the province. STAY TUNED!
We hope you enjoyed this article! If you would like to submit your hockey story to be published on this site, we will definitely be interested and proud to display it. It could be anything from how your team did in a tournament, to an exceptional game your team played or an individual had. Please email your story and pictures to yourstory@hockeyneeds.com
Posted in Michael’s Corner and tagged featured
About Michael Orlotti
Michael has played various levels in Minor Hockey in the old MTHL league, High School Hockey at C.W. Jeffrey’s C.I., College Hockey with Seneca Braves – Now Called Seneca Stingers and was invited to play in Italy for the HC Milano Vipers. Attained his National Coaching Certification Level I & II from Hockey Canada. Also, Coached & Trained Players at various levels starting at the House League and through the GTHL A to AAA levels
